When the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM) was launched in December 2005, it became the largest urban development programme the country had ever attempted. Backed by an initial central commitment of around ₹50,000 crore and eventually channelling assistance to more than 60 cities, the mission set out to fix two things at once: the crumbling physical infrastructure of fast-growing cities, and the weak, opaque institutions that managed them. By the time it concluded in 2014, JNNURM had reshaped how municipalities budget, build, and serve residents. Understanding its outcomes helps explain why later schemes like AMRUT and Smart Cities look the way they do.
Table of Contents
- Financial reforms and governance
- From cash books to double-entry accounting
- Strengthening own revenues
- Enhanced urban services
- Water supply and sanitation
- Reaching the urban poor
- Public-private partnerships
- Community empowerment
- Participation through reform
- Long-term urban sustainability
- Designing for self-reliance
- An honest assessment
Financial reforms and governance
The most lasting outcome of JNNURM was not a flyover or a pipeline. It was a quiet revolution in how cities keep their books. Central grants were deliberately tied to reforms, so a municipality could not simply take the money and continue with business as usual. To unlock funds, urban local bodies (ULBs) had to commit to a defined set of mandatory and optional reforms within an agreed timeline.
From cash books to double-entry accounting
For decades, most Indian municipalities ran on simple single-entry cash accounting. This told them how much money came in and went out, but almost nothing about what they owned, what they owed, or whether a service was running at a profit or a loss. JNNURM made the shift to an accrual-based double-entry accounting system a mandatory condition for receiving grants. The goal was a modern accounting framework that would bring transparency and reliability to municipal financial reporting.
The practical impact was significant. With a double-entry system, a city’s accounts get segregated cleanly into assets, liabilities, income, and expenses. According to a compendium of good practices, this kind of reform helped municipalities achieve financial discipline by ring-fencing money for specific services and tracking the actual cost and benefit of each activity. Daily and fund-wise reporting also eased the year-end scramble that had long plagued municipal accounts departments.
Strengthening own revenues
Reforms also targeted the revenue side. Property tax was a major focus, with cities encouraged to map properties using Geographic Information System (GIS) tools so they could bring untaxed buildings into the net and let owners self-assess their dues through a transparent formula. User charges on services like water were rationalised so that ULBs could move towards recovering at least part of their operation and maintenance costs. The intent was clear: cities that could generate their own revenue would depend less on grants and become genuine units of self-governance, in line with the spirit of the 74th Constitutional Amendment.
Enhanced urban services
Alongside the institutional reforms, JNNURM poured investment into the visible infrastructure that residents use every day. The mission ran through two main channels: Urban Infrastructure and Governance (UIG) for larger cities, and Basic Services to the Urban Poor (BSUP), supported by parallel schemes for smaller towns. Together they funded water supply, sewerage, drainage, solid waste management, roads, urban transport, and street lighting.
Water supply and sanitation
Water was central to the mission. Before JNNURM, roughly half of all cities lacked piped water supply, and intermittent supply for a few hours a day was the norm. The mission pushed cities towards the ambitious goal of 24×7 water supply and, importantly, introduced service-level benchmarking so that performance could actually be measured and compared. Reliable performance data on indicators like coverage, supply hours, metering, and non-revenue water gave planners the tools to monitor and sustain improvements rather than guess at them.
Sewerage and sanitation saw parallel investment. Cities laid new sewer networks and built sewage treatment plants, which reduced the volume of untreated waste flowing into rivers and improved public health in dense urban neighbourhoods. The reforms tied to these projects also stressed that asset creation had to be linked to asset management, so that a new treatment plant would not fall into disrepair a few years after it was built.
Reaching the urban poor
The BSUP sub-mission was designed so that infrastructure gains would not bypass the poorest residents. It funded integrated slum development, affordable housing, community toilets, water connections, and drainage in low-income settlements. The principle of universal access to a minimum level of services meant that water, sanitation, and shelter were treated as entitlements for everyone in a city, not perks for richer neighbourhoods. This inclusive framing was a notable shift in Indian urban policy, which had often focused on showcase projects.
Public-private partnerships
JNNURM also created momentum for private sector participation in services that were once entirely public. The additional public funding lowered the financial risk of public-private partnerships in sectors like water, and the programme’s appraisal process encouraged cities to consider PPP models. Private partners brought technical expertise and operational efficiency that many ULBs lacked, while performance-linked contracts tied payments to actual service delivery. This was an early, imperfect experiment, but it opened the door to models that cities continue to refine today.
Community empowerment
One of JNNURM’s stated outcomes was greater participation by citizens in how their cities are planned and run. The mission required cities to prepare a City Development Plan (CDP), a long-term vision document that was meant to be built through consultation rather than handed down by a single department. In practice, the quality of participation varied widely, but the requirement itself established the idea that residents have a legitimate voice in shaping urban priorities.
Participation through reform
Several reform conditions had community empowerment built into them. The Public Disclosure Law pushed ULBs to publish key financial and operational information so that citizens could scrutinise how their city was performing. The Community Participation Law aimed to give neighbourhoods a formal structure for involvement in local decisions. As an analysis of water utilities noted, transparency and community participation in service delivery can meaningfully improve how well a utility performs, because residents who can see the data are better placed to hold providers accountable.
In the slum redevelopment component, beneficiary communities were often involved in identifying needs and, in some cities, in the delivery of services and upkeep of shared facilities. A portion of municipal budgets was earmarked for the urban poor, which encouraged the formation of community-based organisations to channel that spending. These were the seeds of a more participatory model of urban governance, even if the seeds did not germinate evenly across all cities.
Long-term urban sustainability
The deepest question about any large programme is whether its gains survive after the funding stops. JNNURM was explicitly designed with this in mind. Grants were structured to link asset creation with asset management, and cities were expected to plan for the full life-cycle cost of a project, including the operation and maintenance expenses that follow construction.
Designing for self-reliance
To make services self-sustaining, the mission asked cities to set up a revolving fund to meet ongoing maintenance needs and to recover costs through rational user charges. Combined with the accounting reforms, this was meant to turn municipalities into financially viable bodies that could eventually borrow from capital markets on the strength of credible, audited accounts. The continuing emphasis on publishing audited annual accounts under later finance commission grants and the AMRUT scheme shows that JNNURM set a direction that successor programmes kept following.
An honest assessment
Sustainability was the area where JNNURM’s reach exceeded its grasp. Many cities adopted double-entry accounting on paper but struggled to maintain it for lack of trained staff, and a large share of ULBs continued to fall behind on completing and auditing their accounts. Project completion was uneven, and several cities found that user charges remained politically difficult to raise. A review of the mission framed JNNURM as an opportunity for sustainable urbanisation that was only partly realised, with environmental sustainability often taking a back seat to immediate infrastructure targets.
Yet the structural legacy is real. JNNURM normalised the idea that grants should come with reforms, that cities should measure service levels, and that financial transparency is a precondition for self-government. Those principles now sit at the core of AMRUT, the Smart Cities Mission, and finance commission grant conditions. In that sense, the most durable outcome of JNNURM was a changed mindset about what an Indian city can demand of itself.
What do you think? If financial transparency and trained municipal staff are what make urban reforms stick, should future schemes spend more on capacity building than on construction? And how much real decision-making power should ordinary residents have over how their city’s infrastructure budget is spent?
References
- https://www.impriindia.com/insights/jawaharlal-nehru-national-urban-missio/
- https://cpgfm.icai.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Accounting-System-of-the-Urban-Local-Bodies-Issues-Challenges.pdf
- https://www.nitiforstates.gov.in/public-assets/Best_Practices/Compendiums/Compendium%20of%20Good%20Practices-%20Urban%20Reforms%20in%20Indian%20cities.pdf
- https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/27970/2007-indian-water-utilities-data-book.pdf
- https://tmc.lsgkerala.gov.in/en/page/125
- https://aspirecircle.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/WSP-Trends-Private-Sector-Participation-India-Water-WASH.pdf
- https://www.janaagraha.org/files/Guidelines-on-Accounting-Audit-Reforms.pdf
- https://iihs.co.in/knowledge-gateway/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/JNNURM-An-Opportunity-for-Sustainable-Urbanisation-Secondary-Review-Analysis_Final.pdf
Leave a Reply