The early historic period, often called India’s “second urbanization”, saw cities rise again across the subcontinent for the first time since the Harappans. From roughly the sixth century BCE, settlements in the middle Gangetic plains grew into fortified towns with markets, coinage, craft workshops and dense populations. But the story of these cities is far from settled. Did they flourish and then collapse into a “dark age”? Or did urban life simply move, adapt and continue under new political masters? These questions sit at the heart of one of the liveliest debates in Indian archaeology, and the answers reshape how we understand the link between political power and the city.
Table of Contents
- What the early historic urban centres were
- Internal trade networks and a shared material culture
- The role of Northern Black Polished Ware
- The debate on urban decline
- R.S. Sharma and the case for urban decay
- The continuity argument
- Political and economic forces behind the cities
- Lateral shifts: cities that moved rather than vanished
- Why the debate still matters
What the early historic urban centres were
When scholars talk about early historic urbanism, they are usually pointing to the cities that emerged in north India after about 600 BCE. Archaeologists use a checklist, drawn from V. Gordon Childe’s idea of the “Urban Revolution”, to decide whether a settlement counts as a city. The markers include large size, clear physical demarcation such as ramparts, monumental public architecture, specialised craft industries, writing, and a system of weights and coinage. Sites like Pataliputra, Kaushambi, Rajghat (ancient Varanasi), Mathura and Hastinapura tick most of these boxes.
This phase is closely tied to a distinctive pottery type, Northern Black Polished Ware (NBPW), a glossy, mirror-finished ceramic that acts as a chronological marker for the period. Its appearance coincides with the growth of the Mahajanapadas and, later, the Mauryan empire. Understanding how these cities connected to one another is the first step toward understanding the debate over their fate.
Internal trade networks and a shared material culture
One of the most striking features of the early historic world is how similar its cities looked, even when separated by hundreds of kilometres. This was not a coincidence. The cities were tied together by dense internal trade networks that moved goods, ideas and technologies across the Ganga plains and beyond.
The clearest evidence comes from Northern Black Polished Ware itself. This re-urbanization was accompanied by massive embankments and fortifications, population growth, wide-ranging trade, specialised crafts such as ivory and shell carving, a system of weights, punch-marked coins and the spread of the Brahmi and Kharosthi scripts. The same fine black pottery turns up from Taxila in the north-west to the lower Ganga in the east and down to the Vindhyas, marking out a broad zone of shared culture.
The role of Northern Black Polished Ware
Although NBPW often made up only a small fraction of the total pottery at any site, its wide distribution tells us a great deal. Researchers who have mapped over a thousand NBPW findspots describe a robust socio-economic network radiating out from the middle Ganga plain. Because this luxury ware required specialised technological know-how that has never been fully reproduced, finding it far from its likely production zones signals long-distance exchange rather than local imitation.
The result was a degree of cultural uniformity that is unusual for such an early period. Cities scattered across the north shared comparable layouts, building techniques, scripts and currencies. This interconnectedness matters for the decline debate, because if cities were bound together by trade, then a disruption to that trade could ripple across the whole urban system at once.
The debate on urban decline
Here the story splits in two. One group of scholars argues that early historic cities went into serious decline after a few centuries. Another insists that urban life continued, simply taking new forms in new places. This is not a minor academic quarrel; it shapes how we read the entire first millennium CE.
R.S. Sharma and the case for urban decay
The most influential argument for decline comes from the historian R.S. Sharma. In his 1987 study Urban Decay in India (c. 300-c. 1000), he examined the material remains of more than 130 excavated sites and read the thinning of construction, craft and commercial activity in their upper layers as evidence of de-urbanization. Sharma placed a particularly sharp phase of urban decay after the sixth century CE, coinciding with the fall of the Gupta empire, when many towns of the middle Gangetic plains shrank or were deserted.
Sharma linked this contraction to his wider Indian feudalism model. As IGNOU’s teaching material explains, the feudal thesis holds that the granting of land to officials, priests and temples drained money out of trade and pushed economic life toward a self-sufficient, rural pattern. Sharma also tied the decline to the collapse of long-distance trade, both with the Roman and Byzantine worlds and with South-East Asia, and he drew support from the travel accounts of Chinese pilgrims such as Faxian and Xuanzang, who described several once-great cities as ruined or thinly populated. The decline of towns, in this reading, was not regression but a structural transformation that produced classical feudalism and agrarian expansion.
The continuity argument
Not everyone accepts this picture. The historian B.D. Chattopadhyaya, in works such as The Making of Early Medieval India, argued that while some urban centres certainly declined, others continued to thrive and new ones emerged. He pointed to towns like Prithudaka (modern Pehoa in Haryana), Tattanandapura (Ahar, near Bulandshahr on the west bank of the Ganga), Siyadoni (near Lalitpur) and Gopagiri (Gwalior), which show signs of continued inland trade and urban activity well into the early medieval period.
Critics of the decline thesis also note that the archaeological record is patchy and may not be reliable enough to prove desertion. As one survey of the trade debate records, Xuanzang himself described some cities as declining, such as Kaushambi, Shravasti and Vaishali, but mentioned others, including Thaneswar, Varanasi and Kanyakubja, as flourishing. Sites such as Ahichchhatra, Atranjikhera, Rajghat and Chirand stayed inhabited across the supposed gap. The numismatist John S. Deyell has further shown that money was not actually scarce in early medieval India, weakening one of the key planks of the de-urbanization argument.
Political and economic forces behind the cities
Step back from the question of decline, and a deeper pattern emerges: the rise and fall of cities was tightly bound up with political change. Cities did not grow or shrink in a vacuum. They responded to who held power, where revenue flowed, and which trade routes were open.
Research on early urbanization repeatedly stresses that organised political and mercantile systems were essential to generating the surpluses that cities needed. The concentration of power in centralised administrations, from the Mahajanapadas to the Mauryas to the Guptas, fed urban growth, while the breakup of those powers could pull the props out from under a city. The classic explanation that iron technology alone “caused” the second urbanization has been steadily revised. Scholars writing on the iron and second urbanization debate now treat iron as one factor among many, alongside agricultural surplus, favourable environment, trade and state formation.
This political-economic lens suggests something important. Rather than thinking of Indian history as having neat, separate “phases” of urbanization and de-urbanization, it may be more accurate to see a dynamic, ongoing pattern in which cities continually rose and declined in step with shifting political fortunes. A so-called “third urbanization” from around the eighth or ninth century onward, in this view, is less a fresh start than another turn of the same wheel.
Lateral shifts: cities that moved rather than vanished
One idea helps reconcile the two camps: the concept of lateral shift. Archaeological surveys often show that urban activity did not simply disappear from a region; instead, it relocated within the same micro-region over time. A site might be abandoned while a new centre rose a short distance away, drawing on the same resources, routes and hinterland.
The shifting numbers of NBPW sites hint at this restlessness. As studies of the urbanization process note, settlement counts rose and fell sharply across the early historic centuries, with sites concentrating, dispersing and re-forming rather than vanishing outright. When this happens, a snapshot of a single excavated mound can look like total collapse, even though the broader region remained urban.
This matters for the decline debate because it changes what “decay” means. If a famous city shows poor upper layers, that may record the abandonment of one location, not the end of urban life across its region. Recognising lateral shifts encourages archaeologists to study clusters of sites together, tracking how urban functions migrated, rather than reading the fortunes of one mound as the fate of an entire civilization.
Why the debate still matters
The argument between decline and continuity is ultimately about how we tell the story of the Indian past. Sharma’s de-urbanization thesis ties the city to long-distance trade and centralised states, and reads its fading as a fundamental social change. Chattopadhyaya’s continuity model treats the city as more resilient, capable of surviving, shifting and reinventing itself even as empires rose and fell. The truth probably lies in holding both insights together. Cities were vulnerable to political and commercial shocks, yet urban life as a whole proved remarkably durable, moving across the landscape rather than disappearing from it.
What do you think? If a city’s archaeological remains grow thin, how should we decide whether that signals genuine decline or simply a lateral shift to a nearby site? And do you find the idea of continuous, overlapping waves of urbanization more convincing than the older model of separate phases of growth and decay?
References
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Black_Polished_Ware
- https://books.google.com/books/about/Urban_Decay_in_India_C_300_c_1000.html?id=LCYiAAAAMAAJ
- https://egyankosh.ac.in/bitstream/123456789/44422/1/Block-4%20Part-I.pdf
- https://www.govtgirlsekbalpur.com/Study_Materials/History/CC5_MOD_4D.pdf
- https://www.heritageuniversityofkerala.com/JournalPDF/Volume4/48.pdf
- https://socialresearchfoundation.com/upoadreserchpapers/2/218/1908130616541st%20kali%20prassanna%20nai.pdf
Leave a Reply