On paper, India’s big cities were supposed to grow in neat, orderly bands. Residential zones here, industrial zones there, commercial strips somewhere else, all separated by clean lines on a master plan. Walk through Delhi, Mumbai, or Bengaluru today, and that vision dissolves almost instantly. Shops sit under flats, workshops share walls with homes, and whole neighbourhoods exist that no plan ever sanctioned. This gap between the planned ideal and the lived reality is not an accident or a failure of effort. It points to something deeper about how planning itself was conceived after independence, and why so many of its core tools never quite fit the cities they were meant to shape.
Table of Contents
- Why post-colonial planning inherited a flawed blueprint
- Zoning and segregation: a Western tool that did not fit
- The logic of single-use zoning
- Why mixed-use suits Indian cities better
- Criticism from planners: adapt, do not imitate
- The impact of unplanned growth: the Delhi story
- Unauthorised colonies and the limits of enforcement
- Social challenges that planning did not anticipate
- What a more grounded approach could look like
Why post-colonial planning inherited a flawed blueprint
When India became independent in 1947, its cities carried the weight of a planning system designed for control rather than community. The British had divided colonial towns into spacious European quarters and congested Indian areas, treating segregation as a planning principle rather than a problem to solve. After independence, planners did not start from scratch. They adopted the master plan as the central instrument of urban development, a top-down document that fixed land uses decades in advance.
Scholars have argued that the trouble with these plans was not poor implementation but the logic baked into them. As urban researcher Gautam Bhan has pointed out, master plans tend to produce illegality after the fact, declaring large parts of a working city unauthorised simply because they did not match a paper vision. The colonial habit of insulating planning from local politics also survived. City Improvement Trusts simply became Development Authorities, bureaucratic bodies that held enormous power over land while remaining distant from the people who actually lived in these neighbourhoods.
Zoning and segregation: a Western tool that did not fit
At the heart of the critique sits one imported idea: single-use zoning. This is the practice of dividing a city into separate zones where only one activity is allowed, so that homes, shops, offices, and factories each get their own designated patch. It emerged in Western cities to push polluting industry away from residential areas and to impose a certain visual order. Indian planners borrowed it wholesale.
The logic of single-use zoning
Zoning assumes that people can comfortably travel between where they live, where they work, and where they shop. It assumes private vehicles, reliable public transport, and households that do not earn their living from the spaces they occupy. For a large share of urban Indians, none of these assumptions hold. A tailor who runs a shop from the front room of her house, a family that rents out a floor to supplement income, a vegetable seller who works the lane outside his home, are all violating zoning rules by simply earning a living. The tool treats ordinary economic survival as a planning offence.
Why mixed-use suits Indian cities better
The alternative that critics champion is mixed-use development, where homes, shops, small workshops, and services share the same street or even the same building. This is not a foreign concept that needs importing. It describes how most Indian neighbourhoods have always worked, from the lanes of Shahjahanabad to the bazaars of any small town. Mixed-use keeps daily needs within walking distance, supports informal livelihoods, and creates the busy, watched streets that tend to feel safer.
The intellectual case against rigid zoning was made decades ago by the urbanist Jane Jacobs, who argued that separating uses drains the life out of streets and that mingling them is what makes a neighbourhood thrive. Indian planning practice has slowly, and reluctantly, come around to this. The Delhi Development Authority eventually had to introduce relaxed mixed-use norms on designated streets, effectively legalising in part what residents had been doing anyway. The fact that this had to be conceded shows how poorly the original separation matched the city’s economic reality.
Criticism from planners: adapt, do not imitate
The objection that runs through decades of writing on Indian urbanism is simple to state and hard to act on: cities here should adapt planning to local conditions rather than copy Western models line for line. Western planning concepts travel widely, but they rarely survive the journey intact. One study tracing the migration of planning models across the world found that ideas like the garden city or functional zoning were absorbed in name while their substance bent completely out of shape on the ground. A mapping exercise in Delhi found that the master plan’s zoning rules were being flouted almost universally.
This is why so many Indian planners have grown sceptical of the master plan as a tool. A.K. Jain, a former planning commissioner of the Delhi Development Authority, has argued that master plans will not deliver results as long as multiple authorities with overlapping powers keep working at cross purposes. Officials at the National Institute of Urban Affairs have echoed the same point. The critique is not that planning is unnecessary, but that a planning style built around fixed, comprehensive, decades-long blueprints cannot keep pace with how cities here actually grow. When a plan and a living city disagree, the plan does not win. It simply gets ignored, and the gap between them widens into a governance crisis.
There is a sharper version of this argument too. Critics point out that imported planning frameworks often reproduce the very inequity they claim to fix. Formal systems modelled on Euro-American cities tend to assume a uniform, serviced, middle-class resident, and they leave segregation intact by pushing the poor to the margins or out of the legal city altogether. The result is that the formal plan serves a minority while the majority builds its own informal arrangements to meet basic needs.
The impact of unplanned growth: the Delhi story
No city illustrates the consequences of this mismatch more clearly than Delhi. The capital has had a series of master plans since 1962, each promising orderly, zoned development. What it actually produced was a sprawling parallel city that the plans never accounted for.
Unauthorised colonies and the limits of enforcement
Unauthorised colonies are residential neighbourhoods that grew in violation of zoning rules or on subdivided agricultural land, without the Development Authority’s sanction. They are not slums in the usual sense. Many are solid, settled places where people bought plots and built homes, but always outside the official plan. Their growth has been relentless. Delhi had around 110 such colonies in the 1960s, housing a couple of hundred thousand people. Today there are well over a thousand, home to around 40 lakh residents who navigate uncertain ownership rights and patchy basic services.
The state’s response exposed the futility of enforcement. Instead of preventing these colonies, successive governments simply regularised them in waves, each time promising it was the last. A former urban development minister bluntly called the whole pattern a product of bad planning rather than weak enforcement, asking how anyone could realistically police 1,600 irregular colonies after the fact. When a city has to keep passing special laws to legalise what its own plan forbade, the plan has clearly lost touch with the city.
Social challenges that planning did not anticipate
Unplanned growth carried real costs that the zoning vision never foresaw. Colonies built without sanction often lack open spaces, parks, and community areas, since land use in them runs almost entirely to housing. Residents struggle to get formal bank loans against semi-legal titles, which traps capital and limits how families can improve their lives. Drainage and water systems, designed for a planned population, buckle under densities they were never meant to serve. The repeated urban flooding in cities like Chennai and Bengaluru is partly a story of growth racing ahead of the infrastructure that plans assumed would arrive in step.
The scale of the problem is national, not just metropolitan. A 2021 review found that about half of statutory towns lack master plans entirely, and that even where plans exist, long delays in notifying them leave cities to grow with no guiding framework at all. Delhi itself spent years effectively governed without an active plan while its population nearly doubled. Unplanned growth, in other words, is not the exception that escaped the system. For a large part of urban India, it is the system.
What a more grounded approach could look like
The critiques add up to a fairly consistent prescription. Planning should treat mixed-use as the norm rather than a grudging exception. It should build flexibility into land-use rules so that ordinary livelihoods are not criminalised. It should reduce the tangle of overlapping authorities so that a single accountable body can act. And it should plan with residents rather than over their heads, recognising that the people living in so-called unplanned areas often understand their own neighbourhoods better than a distant blueprint ever could. [Image: A dense Indian neighbourhood street showing shops on the ground floor and homes above, illustrating organic mixed-use development]
None of this means abandoning planning. It means letting go of a particular inherited model, the comprehensive master plan with its rigid zones, that was borrowed at independence and never honestly tested against the conditions it was meant to govern. The chaos in Indian cities is real, but it is at least as much a verdict on the tools as on the cities themselves.
What do you think? If single-use zoning has repeatedly failed to match how Indian cities actually live and work, should planners formally make mixed-use the default and redesign rules around it? And when a master plan and a real, lived-in neighbourhood collide, whose vision of the city should carry more weight?
References
- https://www.resilience.org/stories/2021-10-07/radically-rethinking-urban-planning-in-and-from-the-global-south/
- https://casi.sas.upenn.edu/iit/mathewidiculla
- https://dda.gov.in/sites/default/files/inline-files/Master_Plan_for_Delhi_2021_text_report.pdf
- https://cityterritoryarchitecture.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40410-020-0113-0
- https://www.pressreader.com/india/hindustan-times-gurugram/20180211/281569471188485
- https://www.urbanet.info/urban-planning-colonialism-india/
- https://scroll.in/article/1005716/delhi-master-plan-2041-a-half-step-forward-for-unauthorised-colonies-but-more-is-needed
- https://www.deccanherald.com/archives/unauthorised-colonies-due-bad-planning-2362754
- https://india.mongabay.com/2024/07/rethinking-master-plans-for-indias-growing-cities/
Leave a Reply